Personal Defense Network Editors

Handgun Modifications or Training?

Personal Defense Network Editors
Duration:   3  mins

Description

What makes someone a better defensive shooter: modifying their carry gun or training and practicing more? Riley Bowman of ConcealedCarry.com feels strongly about the subject of modifications to handguns.

Students have attended his classes with compensators, ported barrels, and trigger jobs that might make the gun really cool but don’t necessarily make the person using the gun a better defensive shooter.

Time and Money

Although these modifications may help shooters make some otherwise impossible shots that have nothing to do with defensive shooting, they do not help students learn the fundamental application concepts. What does Riley recommend for how beginning shooters should spend their time and money?

Riley encourages shooters to spend their money on ammunition and their time on training and learning the skills. Once a shooter has established the baseline skills through handgun training and practice, some handgun modifications are worthwhile.

Which Modifications Make Sense?

Riley believes that modifications that make handling and using the gun easier are good investments. These include adding an extended magazine release and extended slide stop. Replacing the less-than-ideal factory sights with improved sights is a plus for many handguns. Improved sights can help you establish a sight picture with trickier shots. Also, considering the low- or no-light conditions most defensive encounters take place in, a weapon-mounted light is a great tool to have added to your handgun.

The Bottom Line

It’s the old hardware versus software question: Your gear is not going to save you if you don’t have the skills. The best plan may be to do some training and practice first to become familiar with your carry gun, work on shooting drills, then see which of the above modifications will benefit you, add them, and get back out and train and practice some more.

Share tips, start a discussion or ask other students a question. If you have a question for the instructor, please click here.

Make a comment:
characters remaining

4 Responses to “Handgun Modifications or Training?”

  1. Robert A Maddocks Jr

    I've been advised by more than one expert - legal and equipment - to keep you carry handgun pretty close to OEM. Many purport that a lot of exotic mods can cause you legal problems in the aftermath of a shooting. It's primarily a problem of perception, but can be a factor. Just saying.

  2. Joe

    Really good advice. One thing I have learned from the military. You have to be able to pick up any firearm including a downed threats firearm and be able to accurately fire it. Only modifications that I see are for disabled shooters.

  3. Wayne

    I take some exception to the weapon mounted light. There is a time and place for everything, and this is speaking just for me however here goes. My personal weapons are not light equipped, however I have 40 years experience using them. I was recently issued a Glock with the light mounted and while it is only a few ounces I notice a "sluggishness" in handling this weapon. I am absolutely aware that you have to have adequate light to identify the threat and that there are areas that are dark enough that the weapons mounted light is the correct answer unfortunately these areas are less and less common. In 30 plus years of semi rural law enforcement and 6 years of military application I have not personally found a time that the speed of a close quarters confrontation is something I am willing to trade for the stated sluggishness in handling of the mounted light on a handgun. I feel a mounted light belongs on long guns only. Just my humble opinion and I be I take a beating on that.

  4. jsl55

    Good advice. I have several Glocks and make only a couple mods to them. I do have different fiber optic or tritium sights on them, but some mods I make to all of them. Extended mag and slide stop releases and a Ghost 4.5 lb connector on all of them. That way I can pick up any of them and have them work and operate basically the same as any of the others.

Riley, thanks for joining me today. You know, you're really passionate about this topic of appropriate modifications, and even this idea really, what's more important modifications or training. What do you see when you go to the range that frustrates you when it comes to modifications? Many of the frustrations I have at the range are students that show up with compensators, ported barrels, fancy triggers, that don't necessarily make them a better defensive shooter. Right. It might help us split time or something like that, or help you hit golf balls at 50 yards, or that crazy turning your striker fired gun into a single action kind of trigger, maybe even bypassing safeties. These things don't really help you learn the fundamental application concepts. What do you suggest for people who are, especially the ones that are just getting started, where they spend the money, where they spend the time? I'd recommend they spend the money on their ammunition, and time spent actually training and learning the skills. That's sound advice to me. It's certainly something that we've advocated for a long time at Personal Defense Network. But you do have some opinions on modifications that are worthwhile. Maybe not day one, but certainly once you've established the baseline skills, what are you guys recommending at concealedcarry.com? What modifications make sense? Yeah, I think modifications that makes sense, are things that make handling and using that gun a little bit easier. For instance, you get a lot more positive extraction of magazine if you have maybe an extended magazine release. Or, it's a little bit easier to get that slide locked back with an extended slide stop. Definitely one thing that makes a lot of sense, because most defensive encounters occur at less than ideal conditions as far as lighting's concerned. A weapon mounted light is a great tool to have. Also, better sights, because a lot of times from the factory guns come with less than ideal sights. If that helps you a little bit, establish that sight picture, you know, with trickier shots, then those are some very easy modifications to do that make a lot of sense. Yeah. I agree with you. I tell most people, you know, stock is the way to go. Certainly with the trigger. I very rarely see a shooter on the range who isn't already really good with any kind of aftermarket advanced trigger, even a polished job on their trigger, that really makes them that much better, especially in the defensive shooting context. But sights, absolutely. A lot of the sights that come from the factory aren't worth having on the gun. And if anything, they're set up with a very narrow rear notch for extreme precision, shooting at a tight group from a bench. But I like the wide rear notch. I like obviously a front face that's flat on the rear sight, that's a great mod. And a lot of people have that... They're 95% of the way there to a perfect grip on their gun, and when they put the extended magazine release on, it's that much easier from the drop that mag without looking, without worryin' about it, more reliably. As long as it's not so big that it pops out when you put it in the holster. So I definitely agree with you on those two points. The underlying thing here is that your gear is not gonna save you if you don't have the skills. It's that software versus hardware thing. Absolutely. So spend more time on the ammunition and the training, as opposed to wasting money on the gun. Yep, I agree. There may be a time for modifications and some of them might even be important, but overwhelmingly if you're serious about being prepared for personal defense, get the training, get the practice.
Get exclusive premium content! Sign up for a membership now!